BOONE – Joey Aguilar threw four touchdown passes to four different receivers as Appalachian State defeated Old Dominion 28-20 on Saturday at Kidd Brewer Stadium, overcoming a statistical disadvantage with timely defensive plays and efficient red zone execution.
Despite being outgained 498-396 in total yards, the Mountaineers (4-4, 2-3) capitalized on three Old Dominion fumbles to secure the victory in front of 34,954 fans. The win demonstrated App State's resilience in their return to Kidd Brewer Stadium, where they had played just one game in the previous 37 days due to Hurricane Helene's impact in September.
Aguilar completed 13 of 24 passes for 212 yards with one interception, connecting with his receivers for crucial scores throughout the game. Kaedin Robinson led App State's receivers with 78 yards, including a 23-yard touchdown catch in the first quarter that opened the scoring. The Mountaineers also got touchdown receptions from Dalton Stroman (46 yards), Kanen Hamlett (4 yards), and Max Drag (11 yards).
Old Dominion (4-5, 3-2) controlled much of the game statistically, with quarterback Colton Joseph throwing for 332 yards and two touchdowns on 27-of-38 passing. Isiah Paige had a standout performance with 13 catches for 205 yards and a touchdown, consistently finding open space and accumulating 157 yards after the catch. Running back Aaron Young added 110 yards rushing on 14 carries, averaging 7.9 yards per attempt.
The Monarchs jumped ahead 17-7 in the second quarter on touchdown passes from Joseph to Diante Vines (14 yards) and Paige (28 yards). However, App State responded quickly when Aguilar found Stroman for a 46-yard score just 79 seconds later, shifting momentum before halftime.
App State's defense made key plays in crucial moments, with Joshua Donald recording two sacks and forcing a fumble. Brendan Harrington led the defensive effort with nine tackles, while the Mountaineers' pass rush accumulated five sacks for 22 yards. The defense particularly excelled in the fourth quarter, holding Old Dominion scoreless while protecting their lead.
The Mountaineers' ground game was led by Ahmani Marshall, who rushed for 120 yards on 23 carries. Aguilar contributed to the rushing attack with 61 yards on seven carries, averaging 8.7 yards per attempt. The balanced offensive approach helped App State control the clock in key situations, particularly in the fourth quarter where they held possession for 11:38.
Old Dominion's offensive efficiency was evident in their 26 first downs and 6.7 yards per play, but turnovers proved costly. The Monarchs moved into App State territory multiple times but saw promising drives end with fumbles, including a critical turnover in the fourth quarter that led to the Mountaineers' final touchdown.
The red zone told the story of the game, with App State scoring touchdowns on all three of their visits inside the 20-yard line, while Old Dominion managed just one touchdown in four red zone trips, settling for two field goals from Ethan Sanchez.
During halftime, former App State quarterback Armanti Edwards was recognized for his upcoming induction into the 2024 College Football Hall of Fame class. Edwards will be officially inducted on December 10 in Las Vegas as part of the 2024 College Football Hall of Fame Class.
The victory keeps App State's bowl hopes alive as they look to build momentum in the final stretch of their season. For Old Dominion, the loss marks a missed opportunity to strengthen their position in the conference standings despite their statistical advantages in the game.