ROCKY MOUNT – The NC Wesleyan Battling Bishops held off a late surge from the Methodist Monarchs to secure a 19-17 victory in a closely contested matchup that showcased contrasting offensive styles.
NC Wesleyan’s big-play offense proved decisive, with quarterback Chaz Hirschman connecting on touchdown passes of 65 and 27 yards to Anthony Byrd and Christian Drumgoole, respectively. Despite attempting fewer passes, Hirschman averaged 12.5 yards per attempt compared to Methodist quarterback Brennan Brucato’s 6.2, finishing with 225 passing yards on just 10 completions.
The Bishops struck quickly in their opening drive, as Hirschman found Byrd for a 65-yard touchdown pass just 62 seconds into the game. Methodist responded in the second quarter with a 23-yard field goal by Samuel Andrae, cutting the deficit to 6-3 at halftime.
The third quarter saw an explosion of scoring from both teams. Byrd, who finished with 150 rushing yards on 22 carries, extended NC Wesleyan’s lead with an 8-yard touchdown run. Methodist answered when Sajari Love scored on a 12-yard run, bringing the score to 13-10. Drumgoole’s 27-yard touchdown reception pushed the Bishops’ advantage back to nine points.
In the fourth quarter, Methodist mounted a comeback attempt. Brucato connected with Love for a 7-yard touchdown pass with 1:32 remaining, but the Bishops managed to run out the clock on their final possession.
Despite the loss, Methodist dominated time of possession, holding the ball for nearly 34 minutes compared to NC Wesleyan’s 26. The Monarchs ran 76 plays to the Bishops’ 59 but averaged less yardage per play (4.8 to 6.9).
Methodist’s balanced offensive approach resulted in 361 total yards, with Brucato completing 18 of 33 passes for 203 yards and the late touchdown. Love led the Monarchs’ ground game with 71 yards on 15 carries and added 83 receiving yards on six catches.
Drumgoole was Hirschman’s primary target, catching five passes for 92 yards. The Bishops accumulated 407 total yards, with 182 coming on the ground and 225 through the air.
Defensively, Methodist’s Omar Goodwin led all tacklers with 10, including one tackle for loss. The Monarchs recorded two sacks on Hirschman, while the Bishops brought down Brucato once.
Penalties played a significant role in the contest, with NC Wesleyan flagged 13 times for 139 yards, nearly double Methodist’s 8 penalties for 65 yards.
Both teams struggled in key situations. Methodist converted 8 of 18 third downs but failed on their lone fourth-down attempt. NC Wesleyan managed just 3 conversions on 11 third-down attempts.
In the kicking game, Methodist’s Kenneth Schoene averaged 37.6 yards on five punts, while NC Wesleyan’s Braxtyn Green averaged 28.8 yards on four attempts. Green missed an extra point attempt that could have proved costly in the close finish.
Up Next
Both teams are at home in USA South conference action as NC Wesleyan (1-4, 1-2) hosts LaGrange at Vernon T. Bradley, Jr. Stadium while Methodist (1-4, 1-2) invites Huntingdon to Monarch Stadium in Fayetteville.