BOONE – The first warning came from above the scoreboard.
Kickers were warming up at Kidd Brewer Stadium on Saturday afternoon when lightning flashed near the large App State "A" atop the scoreboard. Thunder followed almost immediately, exploding through a stadium where the surrounding mountains seem to hold onto the sound.
Then came two more quick flashes.
Players warming up on the field ran for cover. The bands, which had just made their way into the stadium, hurried back out.
The waiting began.
What was supposed to be a 6 p.m. kickoff between App State and Charlotte became 7, then 8, then 9. Every additional lightning strike restarted the process. Updates posted to social media became obsolete and needed to be updated again.
Fans were forced to leave Kidd Brewer Stadium. Some returned to their tailgates. Students went back to their dorms. By about 90 minutes into the delay, cars could be seen leaving parking lots around the stadium.
Saturday's Old North State Showdown was slowly losing its crowd before either team had played a down.
But it didn't lose all of it.
When the gates finally reopened, a few hundred App State students rushed toward the student section behind the Mountaineers' bench and the hill in the south end zone. More trickled in over the next hour, some arriving well into the first quarter.
By halftime, the student sections looked surprisingly normal.
The rest of Kidd Brewer did not.
Three and a half hours after the game was scheduled to begin, at 9:32 p.m., Charlotte finally kicked off to App State.
And those who stayed made themselves heard.
The students roared after big hits. The first App State touchdown brought a blast from the cannon, fireworks and a cheer that sounded larger than the crowd that remained.
It wasn't the Black Saturday atmosphere envisioned when the game was scheduled for 6 p.m. under the lights.
But after three and a half hours of waiting, it was still football.
That alone seemed worth celebrating.
The players had been waiting even longer.
App State coach Dowell Loggains pointed out afterward that the delay didn't simply mean sitting around a locker room until the storm passed. Players had begun preparing hours earlier.
"You start taping about 3:00," Loggains said. "You're starting to do all these stretches and warm-ups and starting to get ready, and then you got to cool down, you got to get going again. You got to cool down, you got to get going."
Charlotte had its own logistical problem.
The 49ers had eaten their pregame meal at 1:20 p.m. By the time kickoff arrived, more than eight hours had passed.
Charlotte coach Tim Albin said staff members scrambled during the delay to get additional food for the players, even making a store run and putting together peanut butter and jelly sandwiches.
Albin admitted he began wondering just how late they could realistically start.
He was concerned kickoff might be pushed to 10.
Instead, at 9:32, there was finally football.
And perhaps fittingly after such an unusual pregame, neither team played particularly clean football once it began.
Charlotte received an early opportunity when App State muffed a punt and former Mountaineer Khamani Alexander recovered it at the App State 36.
For a 49ers team that entered the night 0-2, it was an opportunity to seize immediate momentum.
They couldn't.
Charlotte's ensuing field-goal attempt was disrupted, and the 49ers came away empty.
App State responded with a 41-yard James London field goal and began establishing itself as the better team, though never quite delivering the blow that would put Charlotte away.
The Mountaineers extended their lead late in the second quarter with a 14-play, 74-yard drive that consumed nearly seven minutes. Jaquari Lewis finished it with a two-yard touchdown run.
It was 10-0.
Charlotte's offense had struggled to establish much of anything. The 49ers couldn't consistently run the football, couldn't stay ahead of the chains and repeatedly stalled on third down.
Then, just before halftime, something clicked.
Cole Gonzales directed an eight-play, 68-yard drive in only 71 seconds. A 33-yard completion to Jaylen Hampton helped push Charlotte downfield before Alexander scored from one yard out with 35 seconds remaining.
The former Mountaineer had pulled Charlotte within 10-7.
But the 35 seconds Charlotte left behind mattered.
App State quickly moved into field-goal range, and London connected from 47 yards as time expired.
After a three-and-a-half-hour delay, the teams finally went to halftime with App State ahead 13-7.
The Mountaineers looked like the better team.
They just didn't look like a team ready to finish Charlotte off.
That continued early in the second half.
App State drove to Charlotte's 1-yard line on its opening possession but was stopped on fourth down.
For the 49ers, it was exactly the kind of stand that could change a game.
Then they gave the opportunity back.
With Charlotte backed up near its own end zone, Khalil Conley intercepted Gonzales and gave App State the ball at the Charlotte 27.
Four plays later, Malachi Singleton found Chris Lofton for a three-yard touchdown.
App State led 19-7.
Early in the fourth quarter, Singleton connected with Jackson Grier for another score.
Now it was 26-7.
There were 12:08 left.
After hours of weather delays followed by nearly three quarters of football, this finally appeared to be the moment App State would land the knockout punch.
It never came.
Instead, Charlotte started making plays.
The 49ers drove 75 yards in 12 plays, with Alexander again finishing from one yard out. He ran in the two-point conversion himself.
26-15.
Still, it felt more like a late score that made the final margin respectable than the beginning of a comeback.
App State needed to run out the clock.
When Dre Walker intercepted Gonzales with 2:17 remaining, it appeared finished.
Charlotte had no timeouts remaining. App State had possession.
Game over.
Except this Old North State Showdown had already spent the entire evening refusing to operate according to schedule.
On third-and-five, Singleton threw.
Charlotte defensive back Collin Gill read it, stepped in front of the pass and suddenly had nothing but open field between himself and the end zone.
Thirty-six yards later, Charlotte had a touchdown.
26-21.
The reaction from the App State crowd wasn't anger as much as disbelief.
Silence washed over the home fans.
How was this happening?
North Carolina football fans had already seen one bizarre ending earlier Saturday. NC State's game against Vanderbilt had ended in stunning fashion when a Wolfpack fumble in the end zone on the final play was recovered by the Commodores.
Now, after midnight in Boone, another strange finish suddenly seemed possible.
A game App State had led by 19 points had come down to an onside kick.
Afterward, Loggains took responsibility for the decision that opened the door.
"I don't think we put Malachi in a good spot," he said. "We've got to put him in a better spot in that situation. So you can put that one on me."
Charlotte's sideline had life.
The App State crowd had nerves.
And the whole scene felt surreal.
Six hours earlier, nobody knew when, or even whether, the game would begin. Fans had been sent away. Players had warmed up and cooled down repeatedly. Charlotte staff members had gone looking for food. Cars had disappeared from parking lots. Students had gone back to their dorms.
Now it was Sunday morning, and all of it had come down to one bouncing football.
Charlotte lined up for the onside kick.
App State recovered.
Only then was it finally over.
The Mountaineers kneeled out the remaining seconds and escaped with a 26-21 victory, improving to 3-0 while Charlotte fell to 0-3.
The final score made the game look considerably closer than much of it had been.
App State finished with 435 yards to Charlotte's 247 and held the ball for more than 33 minutes. The Mountaineers converted seven of 16 third downs while Charlotte managed only one conversion in 11 attempts. Charlotte rushed for just 36 yards.
Singleton completed 28 of 42 passes for 331 yards and two touchdowns. Lofton caught six passes for 90 yards and a score, while London made both of his field-goal attempts.
For Charlotte, Gonzales finished with 211 passing yards. Jaden Barnes, another former Mountaineer, caught 10 passes for 97 yards. Alexander managed only 18 rushing yards on 13 attempts but scored both of Charlotte's offensive touchdowns and added a two-point conversion.
And Gill turned what looked like a routine App State finish into something nobody inside Kidd Brewer expected.
Charlotte never completed the comeback, but Albin's team did fulfill one promise its players said they had made to one another.
"We're going to keep fighting no matter what the scoreboard is," Gill said afterward. "We don't care about the scoreboard. We're going to keep fighting till the clock hits zero."
On this night, getting the clock to zero took longer than anyone could have imagined.
By the end, only a couple thousand fans remained inside Kidd Brewer Stadium.
Those who stayed had spent much of their Saturday waiting. Waiting for lightning to clear. Waiting for another update. Waiting for the gates to reopen. Waiting for kickoff. And finally, waiting to see whether App State could survive a Charlotte comeback that had materialized almost from nowhere.
Midnight came and went without much ceremony.
By then, everyone had been there too long for changing the date to feel particularly important.
What began as Black Saturday had become Sunday morning.
At 12:33 a.m., the clock finally reached zero.
This time, there was nothing left to wait for.






